SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Golden State Of Mind

Basketball Strength and Conditioning Expert Brian McCormick Discusses Stephen Curry Ankle Problems and Potential Solutions

Latest Update:

SpearsNBAYahoo
GState GM Riley says in statement @StephenCurry30 has no structural damage to sprained RT ankle & can play when he passes functionality test
1/10/12 4:53 PM

***********************************************************

Most of the folks I follow on Twitter are for "basketball reasons", and most of those are so-called "statheads".

I follow Brian McCormick (@brianmccormick) because he has very interesting insights into player development and coaching, and judging by the fact that he has 2,245 followers as I'm writing this, many other people feel the same way.

Brian runs a website called "Brian McCormick Basketball" (http://developyourbballiq.com) whose tag is "The Science Behind Basketball Coaching and Player Development". He has published numerous basketball-related books and has had numerous assistant and head coaching stints at various levels of player development (you can check out his full basketball bio here: http://developyourbballiq.com/about/).

Besides his expertise in on-court skills development, Brian also is a strength and conditioning expert. In fact, not only does he have a Masters degree in Sports Science, he is working on his PhD dissertation on the topic of agility and lateral movement in basketball. He even has a paper coming out in the Strength & Conditioning Journal on task complexity in strength training for injury prevention.

Basketball is a game of quick stops and starts. Until he [Curry] improves his foot strike in these conditions, he will be susceptible to further injury, and the Warriors’ success will be inextricably tied to the lateral edge on which he moves. (Brian McCormick)

When Stephen Curry went down with his 7th ankle sprain in the last 15 months the other night, Brian sent me a tweet with a link to an article by Daniel Kamenetzky which was posted in June and discussed some of the issues that might be a cause for concern with Curry's movement biomechanics. I think it's always a good thing to have second and third and fourth (you get the idea) opinions from experts, so I asked Brian if he would be kind enough to write down some of his thoughts on what's going on with Steph and if he thinks anything can be done about it going forward.

So, with that, please give your attention and a kind welcome to Mr. McCormick and read his article after the jump.

Star-divide

The following is written by Brian McCormick.

When I coached in Ireland, I had two players go down with Achilles-tendon injuries. The club’s response was rest and massage. The players were not in great shape at the beginning of the season, and increased their activity level and intensity too quickly, so there were extenuating circumstances. However, I explained to the club and the players that chronic injuries do not happen for no reason. Rest relieved the pain temporarily, but did not fix the problem; as soon as they resumed activity, it hurt again. Eventually, the players went to a stride specialist who identified an issue with their running mechanics which contributed to the injury.

An ankle sprain is an acute injury. However, when an athlete suffers repeated ankle sprains, he may develop chronic ankle instability.

An ankle sprain is an acute injury. However, when an athlete suffers repeated ankle sprains, he may develop chronic ankle instability. As with my players, there is generally a cause for a chronic injury. Rest is insufficient to fix the problem.

In the case of Stephen Curry, the problem would appear to be his stride pattern: he contacts the ground initially on the external border of his foot. In this clip of Curry’s injury against the Kings, his body is in good position: he stops with his foot outside his knee and his knee outside his hip. This body position should create sufficient lateral force to stop his momentum and enable a change of direction. However, he appears to load the outside of the foot; ideally, the foot should pronate with the weight toward the inside of his foot on ground contact to decelerate and change directions.

In Curry's situation, I would expect upper-body sway or another movement deficiency that would cause this issue (his body positioning was not as good in this clip against Eric Gordon, but in the last frame, you can clearly see the loading on the external border of his foot.) However, there is little sway; his change-of-direction technique is good. Instead, the problem is his normal gait, as Daniel Kamenetzky pointed out on his blog that he loads the external border of his foot when walking and running. With this type of motion, he is always on the edge of an ankle sprain.

The issue for most players after an ankle sprain is regaining strength and range of motion. When I coached in Ireland, I watched one of my players shoot free throws in our first practice and asked him about his hurt ankle. He said that it had happened over a year ago. However, it affected his shooting. He had a limited range of motion due to incomplete rehabilitation from the injury. He learned a new motor program to compensate for the reduced range of motion, so even when his ankle "felt better", there were negative consequences from the injury.

For a player like Curry with multiple ankle sprains, each additional sprain leads to the weakening or stretching of the ligaments, resulting in increased instability and laxity and decreased proprioception. While strengthening exercises, balance exercises, and other traditional rehabilitation protocols will help to reduce the injury, strengthen the muscles around the joint, and return some proprioception, two issues will remain: (1) the stretched and weakened ligaments and (2) the same stride mechanics with the loading on the external border of the foot. His motor program essentially puts him at risk for injury, as "normal" movement for him is loading first on the lateral aspect of the foot. Any dynamic movement makes controlling his center of gravity difficult due to this ground contact pattern coupled with the increased instability of so many previous sprains.

Like my players who did not improve until they saw a stride specialist and began a program to retrain their movement patterns, Curry will continue to be susceptible to frequent ankle injuries until he changes his movement patterns. Rather than rush him into the line-up this season, an extensive rehabilitation program with a stride or movement expert would appear to be the best course of action for the longevity of his career.

Without a change in his movement patterns, his offense and defense will be affected. As visible in the videos above, even when his body is in a good position to decelerate, he sprains his ankle. Therefore, there is little that he can do to improve his basketball technique to avoid further injury. Basketball is a game of quick stops and starts. Until he improves his foot strike in these conditions, he will be susceptible to further injury, and the Warriors’ success will be inextricably tied to the lateral edge on which he moves.

16 recs  |  53 comments

Comments

Very

Interesting read. It makes sense that due to the injuries consistently happening it is more of an issue of Steph’s mechanics. There is no doubt Steph needs to get it fixed before stepping on the court again. My only question is after working with a stride specialist, how will he be able to adjust his natural tendencies to move and run as he always has, and how will that affect his game?

If my experience is a judge, Curry fix his gait through repetition

I had lower back pain (& strains) before I went into physical therapy. They did about an hour of movement tests, and put me on a program to increase flexibility in my hips and to strengthen my core. In about 6 weeks, I was able to re-learn basic movement to fix the fundamental problem causing the back issues. Now I’m pain/injury free.

nice article

Sounds like at least there is some hope for Steph but he will need a lot of work. Disappointing that the Warriors didn’t even look into this during the lockout. Probably need to shut him down and teach him to walk/run correctly while he still has a chance.

nice article but...

it makes sense but why does he use the example of the clipper game? Steph came down on Blake’s foot. You will roll your ankle every time there no matter how good your mechanics are. Same with the Bulls game.

Not disputing the fact that he sprained his ankle for no good reason at all during Spurs game —→ clearly a mechanics issue, imo.

Steph came down on Blake’s foot

Look more closely.

well, he does kinda kick it on the way through

hey Evanz, thanks a ton for this, love the actual professional opinion, also that summary youtube video is sweet (first time I saw the reverse angle on the most recent injury)

taking what everyone knows

there is generally a cause for a chronic injury. Rest is insufficient to fix the problem.

to providing an actual solution…I hope the Dubs are listening to this

Curry will continue to be susceptible to frequent ankle injuries until he changes his movement patterns. Rather than rush him into the line-up this season, an extensive rehabilitation program with a stride or movement expert would appear to be the best course of action for the longevity of his career.

I only listen to Jason Otter when it comes to basketball

This man is the truth

He would not only fix Curry’s clumsiness and ankle sprains, but he’d turn Curry into the most explosive player in the league behind Lebron. BamBam

oh and rec'd of course. Great read.
Evan...great work and info....sounds like the first logical explanation of this mystery.

I have always noticed as well that Curry “seems” to have a movement/gait almost like a kid on the the playground when he moves sideways after bringing the ball down the court, he also seemed to me appear to be tired or unfocased in his motion compared to the movement of other guards…I finally decided that I was just imagining all that but now I wonder ….

credit goes to Brian, of course

I really appreciate him writing this for us.

OK, somebody forward this to Lacob, please.
This was very interesting. Thanks!
Awesome.

Thanks for obtaining & publishing that piece.

Interesting

So it is Curry’s mechanics that are an issue. Rec’d. I’m not sure what this says about the Warriors training staff though, since they apparently didn’t catch on to this.

Big thanks to Brian McCormick

Great breakdown. I really hope Steph and the Warriors heed this advice:

Curry will continue to be susceptible to frequent ankle injuries until he changes his movement patterns. Rather than rush him into the line-up this season, an extensive rehabilitation program with a stride or movement expert would appear to be the best course of action for the longevity of his career.
great read!

Thanks for this.

So our boy Curry is handicapped…from a professional basketball POV.

I wonder if scouting, researching, and testing a player’s movement will be part of the draft process in the future. It should. Not saying we should not have drafted Curry.

I also wonder if the Warriors know all this already and they’re playing him anyway.

I know that you can learn to avoid injuries by adjusting your game, but it sounds like Brian is saying that given the high level of play for these athletes, it’s basically a non-starter. That whatever adjustments are made, will be made to the detriment of his impact on offense and defense.

I don’t buy it 100% based on personal experience and what Jim Barnett has said on the air (that players eventually learn how to avoid getting injured), but this era of professional athletes, I can imagine, puts so much stress on the body, that every little thing matters.

Great read, Evan (and Brian). Thanks!

meh...
So our boy Curry is handicapped…from a professional basketball POV.

that’s a REAL stretch!
Nowhere does the expert talk about this situation being uncorrectable

Also, if you watch that summary video, the first sprain this season (at about the 30-35 second mark) it looks like he plants nice and flat, his shoe kinda skids a little bit, and that’s when he rolls the ankle. It’s not like he is planting “pinkie toe down”

Everything else afterwards, including all the fancy description just boils down to Curry needing some additional physical therapy…:

For a player like Curry with multiple ankle sprains, each additional sprain leads to the weakening or stretching of the ligaments, resulting in increased instability and laxity and decreased proprioception

that’s a REAL stretch!

That was tongue-in-cheek but in essence, that’s what he’s saying (that Curry is handicapped). I use “handicapped” very loosely here but I don’t know what other word to use. Based on what he’s saying, Curry’s movements aren’t normal, all relative to playing professional basketball, might I add.

Nowhere does the expert talk about this situation being uncorrectable

Nowhere did I insinuate that it wasn’t.

Everything else afterwards, including all the fancy description just boils down to Curry needing some additional physical therapy

I wouldn’t call re-training his movement pattern “physical therapy.” It sounds a little more involved than sticking your ankle in a bucket of beans or using a balance board (I am speaking from experience here).

cool

yeah, after I wrote it I realized who I was responding to and figured I wasn’t giving you enough benefit of the doubt

I just drew the connection of handicapped=inherent and uncorrectably messed up

and finally, you got me

I wouldn’t call re-training his movement pattern "physical therapy."

I have absolutely no idea what this entails

I wasn’t giving you enough benefit of the doubt

A very common mistake people make until they realize who they’re dealing with.

lol

hahaha, that’s it, I’m taking back my respect, and giving it to someone more deserving

reminds me of this meme

Listen to the man

he’s a doctor

I wonder if scouting, researching, and testing a player’s movement will be part of the draft process in the future. It should. Not saying we should not have drafted Curry.

Wasn’t this a major point scouts made against Steph? Lack of lateral quickness, inability to play at the level?

sure, but not with regards to the potential for chronic injury (AFAIK)
I was listening to Tim Brown on 95.7

They were talking about Tim Tebow’s throwing motion and if he could ever learn proper throwing mechanics.

Tim Brown said that it might do worse for Tebow to learn something that’s not comfortable to him naturally. He said that might as well work with what he has rather than risk messing up whatever is working now.

He went onto say that in practice, they would learn the proper way to launch from the line of scrimmage but when game time came around, he just reverted back to what’s natural, which I guess was improper.

I’m not saying a football throwing motion or footwork for a WR is analogous to Curry’s situation, but it does lend me to believe that everything Brian is saying may or may not help Curry, and possibly, may even hurt Curry.

Brian is saying otherwise, that if he doesn’t re-learn his movement pattern, constant injuries will eventually hamper his ability to play basketball at the level that is expected. I can’t really argue that, but I am a little skeptical of Curry’s unforced ankle problems going away.

Given Brian’s reputation, I don’t doubt him. I’m just skeptical. I’m a Warriors fan.

Tim Brown said that it might do worse for Tebow to learn something that’s not comfortable to him naturally

Does this pertain to his potential for being injured or his potential for playing the game? Those are two very different things. Brian is saying he needs to change his mechanics simply to stay healthy and that if he doesn’t do anything, he might very well still be a great shooter, but he won’t last very long. Given the choice between those two, I’d say we’re better off with a 90% Curry who can play rather than a 100% Curry who is constantly out with injury.

dude, just saw your profile pic

please tell me that’s going to be the new logo?!?!?

Given the choice between those two, I’d say we’re better off with a 90% Curry who can play rather than a 100% Curry who is constantly out with injury.

It wouldn’t be that big a difference, probably more like a 100% versus a 99% Binky. I hurt my ankle in high school and it still gives trouble but for long stretches is fine, what causes trouble now is just new injury not routine use of it. If I had to play on it I’d be sure to strengthen it as much as possible, tape it very well, right shoes, etc. then play smart under control ball.
My guess is Binky’s ankle was not 100% strong yet and it got re injured, some medical evaluation, rest, and rehabilitation would make more sense than working on lifetime learned running skills which are more ingrained than learned. You can teach all you want but when crunch time comes the body is gonna do what comes natural.

I’m curious as to whether the surgery has any impact on Curry’s current mechanics. Did anyone check his motion from prior to his injury before writing these articles?

It could have had an impact but it doesn’t mean the surgery was done wrong.

My guess is Binky’s ankle was not 100% strong yet and it got re injured, some medical evaluation, rest, and rehabilitation would make more sense than working on lifetime learned running skills which are more ingrained than learned.

This is probably what they are and have been thinking. Maybe time to re-think, though, given it’s not working.

yeah, well it looks like he will be out through this week

so that is a nice healthy chunk of time off

Does this pertain to his potential for being injured or his potential for playing the game? Those are two very different things. Brian is saying he needs to change his mechanics simply to stay healthy and that if he doesn’t do anything, he might very well still be a great shooter, but he won’t last very long. Given the choice between those two, I’d say we’re better off with a 90% Curry who can play rather than a 100% Curry who is constantly out with injury.

Fair point, but I was also reacting to:

He learned a new motor program to compensate for the reduced range of motion, so even when his ankle “felt better”, there were negative consequences from the injury.
Without a change in his movement patterns, his offense and defense will be affected.

It sounds to me Curry’s injury is not career threatening and he can certainly play regardless of going to Movement Pattern School by getting regular treatment that we’re aware of. It’s just a matter of how well he can play.

My point was that without re-learning his movement, he may still get injured, but he’ll eventually, intrinsically, learn how to avoid getting injured (being conscious of where and how to step, etc.); it actually sounds like Curry has already put this into action based his comments this year (I can’t seem to locate them right now).

Brian’s point seemed to be that he can do this, but he won’t be as good. And there is always concern over the unforced ankle tweak.

I say this all without knowing anything about this movement therapy. I was saying it could be like what Tim Brown is saying: he could learn it in a closed environment, but come game time, will it really make a difference? I know for a fact it won’t help him when he steps on someone’s foot…

I guess it’s about mitigating your risks.

BTW, that’s my ankle doctor in the video in this LINK: Dr. Keith Donatto

He is scheduled to do surgery on my left ankle one of these days. His colleague who is no longer in the area did my previous one, Dr. James Reid. Both are EXCELLENT.

Agree, Doc. One exception. Strengthening the ankle will help, even if he steps on someone's toes!
Maybe this also explain

why Curry get hard time dunking. I can’t think of any 6’3 thats getting a hard time throwing it down…hmmmm…..anyone?

me

I’m about that tall, and maxed out being able to dunk volleyballs in high school (I exploded my ankle in a skateboarding mishap, never been the same since)

oh, and I’m also white, over 30, and out of shape

I’m also white, over 30, and out of shape

Beats being 5’9", Asian, over 30, out of shape, and with Curry-esque ankles (without the pro level treatment).

yeah, you know, there was talk of a GSoM bball game

would have been pretty entertaining to see all of us hermits emerge from our shells (and no doubt get dunked on by some young buck)

Dubbbbyyy! What would a 6'3" point guard be doing on a skateboard? That's hazardous stuff!!! :)
so is a moped :)
hhahaha

I’m deep into motorcycles too (but managed to take my worst wrecks in the dirt while still young enough to bounce back up)

Curry can dunk easily. He chooses not to. It’s not a big deal. Same with say, Steve Nash or Earl Boykins. It’s the NBA, it takes a minimum amount of athleticism/height, and everyone in it can dunk easily.

true

I’d be interested to see how high above the rim Nash can actually get these days though…

maybe

Curry need to start playing soccer. He always can beat by this old man Nash.

*get
I think if we don't deal him by the deadline we should just shut him down and put him through that program

That way we can tank and keep Curry (hopefully)

lol. Once I stopped laughing, I totally agree. His footwork and ankles need total rehab (strengthening) plus mechanics (footwork) to have any longetivity in the NBA.
Evanz, thank you for the great followup initiative to IQ Warrior's extraordinary video documentary of the problem! I think you guys have done a lot to help Steph!

It is always great to get expert confirmation of comments based on experience. I went back and looked at mine on the issue in light of your revealing initiative:

Totally agree. He should come back with an ankle stronger than he has ever had, before he plays a minute of another game!by dinohealth on Jan 6, 2012 10:29 AM PST

Well, you’d be surprised…there is a lot of differing opinions and techniques out there; particularly in pro circles. Does not hurt to get back to basic ankle-strengthening and treatment techniques. You’d also be surprised as to the difference in surgical techniques among orthopods, and , success rates…in pro circles!by dinohealth on Jan 6, 2012 11:28 AM PST

Avoid more surgery at all costs! I think the problem is mechanics. Toe planting vs. heel planting, particularly on lateral movement.by dinohealth on Jan 6, 2012 11:02 AM PST

First, , your video research is AMAZING! Thanks for the great poop!Second, I used a regimen in my career that has helped kids with problematic ankles, also, getting back from ankle injuries:
17 toe lifts with feet wider than shoulder width, toes pointing to the side-as far as possible.
17 toe lifts with feet wider than shoulder width, toes pointing in-as far as possible.
17 toe lifts with feet wider than shoulder width, toes pointing straight ahead.
As the ankles get stronger, add, 5, 10, and 15 lb weights, progressively, on each hand!Does wonders for the calves as well.Good luck, Steph! We need you!by dinohealth on Jan 6, 2012 10:19 AM PST

Right on, Monk. Concurrent physical therapy is hot (whirlpool)/cold(pool-pointed toe paddling/swimming), ultrasound.Solid tape job critical, in addition to high-top shoe. Give up a bit of lateral mobility, to gain some stability. Also, I noticed Steph plants his entire foot when changing direction, laterally. Not good! Needs to stay on his toes like a boxer. Easier on the ankle, and quicker on the change of direction and back-pedal. He practically needs to reinvent his entire balance and motion. Plant feet when situation allows resting, and get up on his toes for movement, especially on defense!by dinohealth on Jan 6, 2012 10:52 AM PST

Not sure at all.

While you guys are all eating this up, I have to say, I am not buying it all. Most of the analysis seems like uninteresting unscientific observation “He lands on the outside portion of his foot”… I see no data that supports the supposition that “landing on the outside of the foot” is wrong. In fact it is what most of us do in our normal gait, some to a great extent, some less. I really don’t think there is a lot of proof that what Steph does is “wrong” per se, only that it is wrong with a less than normal ankle, which he has not had since his first major sprain.

Look, I am no orthopedist or biomechanist, but I am a physician and geneticist, and I just don’t see a lot of data that supports the above theories. Just “this is what he is doing and this is how he should fix it”…I might be fun to speculate, but that is all this is, speculation…I don’t know what will get his ankle right, but I am not sure changing his running mechanics is the answer.

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Golden State Of Mind to post a comment.